What is the best fan out there?

Author: Geym

Mar. 07, 2024

417

0

Tags: Home Appliances

As summers grow longer and temperatures creep higher, a lot of us scramble for the best ways to keep cool—preferably without doubling our energy bills. While air conditioners are the best option once things get really hot, fans are a perfect cooling solution for temperatures under 90 degrees.

If you’re looking to limit your air conditioner use to when it’s really necessary, it makes sense to invest in a really great performing fan. We've tested popular fans to see which delivers the best performance, user experience, and value.

Our results show the Vornado 660 (available at Amazon for $89.99) is the best fan you can buy, capable of some impressive wind speeds even 6 feet away from the fan. While the 660 is our top pick, many of the fans we tested are worth considering or offered something unique that might make it a better option for you.

Credit: Reviewed / Jackson Ruckar

The Vornado 660 was the most powerful fan we tested, capable of producing high speed wind, even at a distance.

Best Overall

Vornado 660

  • Type of fan: Floor fan
  • Dimensions: 15 x 13.5 x 11.8 inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 7.3 pounds
  • Speed settings: 4

The Vornado 660 is the best fan we tested by a significant margin. First and foremost, it’s able to output an impressive volume and air speed, even at a distance. While the Vornado’s wind speeds might be slightly slower than some when measured directly in front of the fan, once you’re a few feet away, the 660 really starts to stand out from the crowd. At a distance of 3 feet, this cooling fan is still able to manage 11.8 mph winds—a faster airflow at a distance than some fans were able to output at all.

We also liked its relatively simple design. It features five buttons along its top, one for power and four for fan strength. These buttons are easy to reach and allow you to skip to your perfect speed without having to cycle through others. The fan head can be rotated vertically to point straight up or at a slight downward angle. It doesn’t have an oscillation feature, instead depending on its strength to create a room-sized air circulation system—something we saw perform well in testing.

At around $100, the 660 offers a lot of power for its price.While the 660 might be more of an investment than some others on our list, Vornado offers a five-year warranty on its products.

Pros

  • Great air speed and volume

  • Maintains breeze over distance

Cons

  • A bit loud on higher settings

$89.99 from Amazon
$95.99 from Best Buy
$89.99 from Walmart
$99.99 from Target

Credit: Reviewed / Jackson Ruckar

The Lasko 3300 Wind Machine offers a lot of power for a low price.

Best Value

Lasko 3300

  • Type of fan: Floor fan
  • Dimensions: 25.38 x 23.38 x 7.19 inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 9.25 pounds
  • Speed settings: 3

The Lasko 3300 Wind Machine came in third place out of all the fans we tested, but merited special mention because of what a great value it is. Not only did it generate a respectable 12.6 mph wind at point-blank range, it was capable of moving the highest volume of air, with over 1,700 CFM (cubic feet per minute) by our measurements.

This being said, the Wind Machine doesn’t blow very far into the room compared to others we tested. Once you get even a few feet away, its wind speed falls by half. Still, if you are in the market for an inexpensive fan to keep nearby, the Lasko Wind Machine is one of the best budget-friendly options out there.

Pros

  • Inexpensive

  • Great wind speed and volume up close

Cons

  • Wind speed falls up sharply over distance

  • Loud

$48.99 from Amazon
$49.99 from Walmart

Credit: Reviewed / XPower

This floor fan truly creates a gust.

Best Floor Fan

XPower FC-200

  • Type of fan: Floor fan
  • Dimensions: 17.3 x 15.4 x 8.9 inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 10.1 pounds
  • Speed settings: 4

There’s a lot to like about the XPower FC-200, which came in second place overall in our testing. It has a rugged plastic construction and a no-nonsense design that features one dial for speed and another that’s a timer. Not only was it capable of the fastest wind speeds at a close distance, it was also one of only two fans to maintain speeds of 10 mph up to 3 feet away from the fan. It moved the second-highest volume of wind, falling right behind the Lasko Wind Machine.

The one downside? It is not a quiet fan. At over 80dB, it was the loudest fan we tested, about on par with a garbage disposal at its highest setting. Even at its lowest setting, the noise level is about the same as a traditional air conditioner.

If you want a solid fan that moves a lot of air and don’t mind making an investment (or a lot of noise), we’d recommend the XPower FC-200.

Pros

  • Very high wind speeds

  • Maintains air flow at a distance

Cons

  • Very loud

Buy now at Amazon
$144.00 from Walmart
$144.00 from Home Depot

Credit: Reviewed / GreenTech

Small yet powerful, this miniature fan fits into any home.

Best Oscillating Fan

GreenTech Environmental pureFlow QT7

  • Type of fan: Desk fan
  • Dimensions: 12.75 x 10.5 x 10.63 inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 6 pounds
  • Speed settings: 12

The GreenTech Environmental Pureflow Circulator is one of the smallest fans we tested, but it puts up some impressive numbers. While it doesn’t have the power of the larger models, it isn’t a slouch either, providing 12.4 mph winds at close range (though that does dissipate quickly with distance). Equipped with 12 speeds, the Pureflow allows for a high level of customization, even if cycling through all those speeds can be cumbersome. Its lower fan speeds are also among the quietest we tested—it’s a great option for an office desk fan.

The Pureflow also has some neat features. As a bladeless fan, it’s safe for kids and pets. It also has oscillation, an intuitive remote, and the ability to tilt 90 degrees vertically. If you don’t mind sacrificing some power for extras, the Pureflow isn’t a bad buy.

Pros

  • Safe for kids and pets

  • Lots of speeds

  • Remote

Cons

  • Wind falls off over distance

  • Cumbersome to scroll through speeds

$99.00 from Amazon
$99.00 from Walmart
$99.00 from Home Depot

Credit: Reviewed / Honeywell

Honeywell delivers decent fan power for a decent price.

Best Tower Fan

Honeywell QuietSet HYF290B

  • Type of fan: Tower fan
  • Dimensions: 40 x 10 x 8 inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 9.2 pounds
  • Speed settings: 8

The Honeywell HYF290B Quietset fell square in the middle of all the fans we tested. With a seemingly cheap build quality, we were initially skeptical, but the Honeywell put up average numbers across the board—nothing to disappoint or impress. We measured its wind speed at a decent 14 mph, but that power didn’t hold up well at a distance. Its lower speeds were fairly quiet, but not the quietest.

Normally when a product doesn’t stand out, we look to its price—anything can be a great value if it's priced low enough. Unfortunately we didn’t get much help here, either. It’s not a steal, but it’s also not overpriced. If you’re looking for a decent tower fan at a relatively reasonable price, the Quietset is fine.

Pros

  • Decent wind speeds up close

  • Lots of speed settings

Cons

  • Felt somewhat cheap

  • Wind speed falls off over distance

$69.99 from Amazon
$83.99 from Best Buy
$72.72 from Walmart
$69.99 from Target

Credit: Reviewed / Rowenta

This fan is quiet, but its performance elsewhere could be better.

Best Standing/Pedestal Fan

Rowenta VU5670U2 Turbo Silence Extreme

  • Type of fan: Pedestal fan
  • Dimensions: 55.12 x 19.69 x 23.62 inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 17.64 pounds
  • Speed settings: 5

We’ve seen the Rowenta VU5551 Turbo Silence standing fan rated highly on other “best fan” lists, but after testing it, we’re not entirely sure why. True to its name, it has a quiet-run mode named “Silent Night” that’s able to produce 3.4 mph winds without exceeding our testing chamber’s ambient noise.

Aside from this feature, however, the Turbo Silence left us feeling confused as to what was justifying its price point. It wasn’t very fast, even with its Power Boost mode enabled. It also required the most set-up by far.

If you absolutely need an inaudible fan, the Turbo Silence might be worth it. Otherwise, we’d recommend the Pureflow Circulator, which was capable of running almost as silently.

Pros

  • Quiet operation

  • Remote

Cons

  • Expensive

  • Requires assembly

$120.70 from Amazon
$120.70 from Walmart
$120.99 from Target
$141.99 from Home Depot

Other Fans We Tested

Dyson Pure Cool TP04

  • Type of fan: Tower fan
  • Dimensions: 41.5 x 8.1 x 4.6 inches inches (height x width x depth)
  • Weight: 10.98 pounds
  • Speed settings: 10

While it's not the most powerful air circulator, the Dyson Pure Cool is the most feature-rich fan in this roundup. If you’re looking for a smart hybrid between a fan and an air purifier, the Dyson Pure Cool is a seriously tempting purchase—even at its high price point.

The main feature we loved about the Dyson Pure Cool was its automatic cleaning mode. When enabled, it sits in standby until its sensors determine air filtration is needed. At that point, the Pure Cool turns on, scrubs the air through its HEPA filter, and automatically turns off again.

It also has loads of other interesting features, like a bladeless design, an LCD display that can show infographics about the air quality of the room, a breezeless air filtration mode, and a remote control that magnetically sticks to the top of the device.

Pros

  • HEPA filter

  • Automatic air filtration mode

  • Remote

Cons

  • Expensive

  • Low air throughput

$549.99 from Amazon

How We Test Fans

The Tester

Hello! I'm Mark Brezinski, and I've been testing and reviewing consumer tech for over a decade. At Reviewed, I’ve spent several years reviewing and developing tests for dozens of different categories, from cell phones to headphones to vacation cruises. And now fans!

The Tests

Credit: Reviewed / Naidin Concul-Ticas

Point A was directly in front of the fan, point B was 3 ft. away, and point C was 6 ft. away. We also took measurements 4 ft. away from points B and C (points D, E, F, and G).

To test the fans, we set up a closed-off testing area to isolate our measurements from any external airflow. Once the fan was up to speed, we took measurements at seven different points in the room: three directly in front of the fan, and four to the sides.

We measured average wind speed at each of these points during a 30-second window and calculated the volume of air being moved (cubic feet per minute, or CFM). We performed the same tests again with oscillation on (if applicable), and recorded the average air movement at each measurement point over five full oscillation cycles.

While a fan’s ability to move air is its primary function, we also tested other aspects of the fans’ performances as well. We measured how much energy the fan required to run at full capacity, both with and without oscillation. We utilized our headphone testing lab to isolate exactly how much noise each fan makes at each of its speeds. We also tested how easy and intuitive the fan’s interface felt to use.

What to Consider When Buying a Fan

Type of Fan

Fans have come a long way since the days of loud box fans sitting in doorways. Now, there are a number of fan varieties available that can be both stylish and quiet.

  • Desk fans. are smaller and As the name suggests, these fans are small enough that they can sit atop a desk while you’re working. Also called table fans, they are a good option for people who like a fan in their bedroom while sleeping. These fans give a user personalized cooling, but often are not as powerful as larger fans.

  • Tower fans. Often more aesthetically pleasing, tower fans are tall and narrow. They also take up less space, which makes them a great option for smaller rooms. That said, they can be powerful enough to help cool large rooms.

  • Floor fans. These are easily portable and can be moved from room to room, wherever they’re needed. More powerful than desk fans, they can help cool large rooms, as they are able to move more air.

Another option would be to invest in a ceiling fan. While they are often more expensive than other types of fans and can be difficult to install, these fans can be used throughout the year—efficiently cooling a room in the summer and making a room warmer in the winter.

Oscillation

Oscillation is where the fan rotates on its base to help spread its breeze around a room. While many of the fans in our test featured oscillation, we found it often had a very minimal impact on overall air movement. While oscillation did allow some fans to distribute airflow across a wider area, the amount of cooling breeze was greatly reduced.

Speed settings

Some of the fans we tested had only three speeds while others had many more than that. The more fan speeds on a fan, the more customization you have with airflow.

Features

Fan features can range from simple, like oscillation, to very advanced, like the Dyson Pure Cool’s automatic cleaning mode. Other special features you might find include whisper mode, sleep mode, energy-saving mode, timer or auto-off, and remote control.

Air conditioners vs. fans

What’s a better cooling option: a fan or an air conditioner? As a general rule, it's best to use a fan for cooling unless temperatures are above 90°F. At that point, the only real option for beating the heat is an air conditioner. At temperatures hotter than 90°F, the fan is basically just buffeting you with hot air, which can actually exacerbate the effects of heat stress on your body. Using an air conditioner for temperatures under 90°F is likely overkill, since a fan will offer decent cooling at 1% of the energy cost.

If you’re looking to keep cool during the hottest months without running up your energy bill, a great cooling fan is your best bet. Used alone or along with your AC, a good fan can help you stay cool and alert during long Zoom calls in your home office or study sessions in your dorm room, and keep your house or apartment a whole lot more comfortable.

We researched hundreds of models and brought 15 highly rated options for testing. Over the course of several weeks, we found that all of the fans did a similarly good job of keeping our test space cool, but varied widely in features, build quality and usability. So while you’ll likely be happy with whichever fan you choose, we’ve picked out the best tower, pedestal and floor fans to suit your space.

Here, our lab testing assistant Gizmo chills out in front of our winning fans.

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

Editor’s Note: Here, our lab testing assistant Gizmo chills out in front of our winning fans.

Our winning picks

Best cooling fan overall: Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room Tower Fan HYF290B

$74 $54 at Amazon; $54 at Target; $68 at Walmart

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

A tower fan gives you great cooling performance with a small footprint, so it’s easy to place in a living room, bedroom or anywhere you’d prefer to tuck an appliance out of the way. Our pick for best tower fan, the Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room tower fan, is well-built, quiet and affordable. It has a solid, stable build and a beautiful, colorfully laid-out control panel that was simpler to figure out and use than the competition, which is why it’s earned the spot as our top pick.

The Honeywell QuietSet was easier to assemble than the other tower fans we tested, with tool-free construction and a simple connection to the base that was a lot easier to deal with than the other tower models. Once we put it together, despite the Honeywell’s light weight, it was more stable than its competitors — some other lightweight towers, like the Lasko, wobbled with a push.

Eight speed settings — more than the other tower fans we tested — give you the ability to fine-tune, though the three lower speeds were very similar in our testing. The clearly labeled controls and comfortable remote made it easy to click through the settings; other models were more finicky and difficult to adjust.

Since it’s likely to be placed in a bedroom, we especially appreciate that the Honeywell let us not just dim its control panel lights but turn them off entirely. None of the other fans we tested offered this kind of control, which let us choose whether we wanted to sleep in total darkness or to just dim the controls so they weren’t distracting.

Best splurge fan: Dyson Purifier Humidity+Cool Formaldehyde PH04 Fan

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

Our pick for best splurge fan, the Dyson Purifier Humidity+Cool Formaldehyde PH04 floor fan is a great fan, air purifier and humidifier all in one unit. It impressed us with its ease of use, sturdy build, fast cooling and quieter performance than the other fans — plus, it doubles as an air purifier and humidifier (we didn’t compare its humidifying function to other fans in this review primarily because none of the other fans offer such a feature).

Like the Dyson Hot+Cool HP04 fan before it, this new model fan can monitor levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and formaldehyde (thus the name). And like the HP04, the PH04 fan offers fine-grained control over its various settings, easy tool-free assembly and well-thought-out front panel controls, including an LCD screen and a handy remote that attaches magnetically on top of the unit for storage.

This Dyson fan also offers an app that lets you control the unit and monitor pollutant levels in your room. If you’re not intimidated by its indulgent price, then it may be well worth the splurge if you’re interested in potentially replacing three separate appliances — fan, air purifier and humidifier — with this one appliance.

Best pedestal fan: Rowenta Turbo Silence Extreme VU5670 Standing Fan

$160 $142 at Amazon; $142 at Target and Walmart

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

While a pedestal fan isn’t as easy to slip into your decor as a tower, it gives you better coverage in larger rooms, since the blades clear your furniture. Our pick for best pedestal fan, the Rowenta Turbo Silence Extreme VU5670, was the sturdiest, best-built and easiest to adjust of the pedestal fans we tested. And with the tallest extension, it should be more usable in larger spaces than the other towers we tested.

The Rowenta was easier to put together than the other pedestal fans, taking us less than 15 minutes to assemble, and it came more securely packed than any other fan we looked at — there was so much cardboard packaging that it gave us pause, even if it is sourced from recycled materials.

Once put together, the heavy base, secure connections and solidly built extension rod made it the most stable of the towers we checked out, even though it adjusted to a taller height than the Black+Decker, Lasko and Honeywell models. The head unit was easy to adjust, with soft clicks indicating the four available angles. The other towers were all stiffer-feeling and more difficult to tweak to a desired position.

Controls were straightforward and easy to use, and the Rowenta’s remote control (which replicates all of the front panel controls) fit nicely in our grip; the remote stores in a slot on the back of the head unit when not in use. Some of the others lacked anywhere to stow the remote, meaning it’s likely to be lost.

Best floor fan: Vornado 660AE Large Air Circulator Fan

$100 at Walmart; $117 at Amazon; $130 at Vornado

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

A floor fan (which can be placed on a desk or table as well) is easy to place almost anywhere, making it great to have on hand to cool a space like a kitchen, office or bath when needed. Our pick for best floor fan, the Vornado 660AE circulator fan is compact, sturdy and powerful, with an adjustable swivel head and the ability to work with Alexa.

Much like our former pick for best floor fan (the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC), the Vornado 660AE was lighter than the other floor fans we tested and easier to carry around our testing space. Still, it was sturdily built and stayed in place solidly wherever we placed it. Its pivoting head was easier to adjust than the other brands and slid back and forth in one smooth, continuous motion. Five silver push-buttons on top of the unit were easily located and let us easily select our desired air flow speed (with four different speeds available).

Left to right: Our top picks for best cooling fans are models from Honeywell, Vornado, Dyson and Rowenta.

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

How to select the best cooling fan for your home

While all of the fans we tested performed well at their fundamental job — moving air around efficiently and saving you from having to crank up your window air conditioner — the type of cooling fan you’ll want to purchase depends on the size and type of space you want to use it in, the size of the fan and your budget. Whatever you select, a fan is a cost-effective way to cool your home, but we have some tips.

A floor fan is great if you need something that’s compact enough to fit on a table or desk, and it’s something you can move around to use as needed. Circulator fans — the design made familiar by Vornado and also found in units like the Black+Decker and Honeywell models we tested — are great examples of personal fans that don’t take up a lot of space.

If you want something more powerful and plan to use it all the time, but also need something space-saving (or you don’t want to make your fan a visual centerpiece in your room), a tower fan is a great choice. With a small footprint and plenty of cooling power, a tower fan is great for a living room or bedroom, where you want to keep the cool air moving without a lot of visual distraction.

A pedestal fan, which places a traditional fan-blade head on top of a long extension pole, is a more in-your-face design choice. But because the blade unit is placed high enough to clear your furniture, it can circulate air through a larger space — it’s great for everything from patios to basements to rec rooms.

Since most fans within a given category work pretty well, budgeting more gives you more features and better aesthetics. You can find super-affordable basic units like the $18 Black+Decker circulator, or scale up to the striking, feature-laden, multipurpose $1,000 Dyson fan.

Whichever you choose, you’ll benefit from better air circulation and should find yourself depending less on your air conditioning.

Some of the cooling fans we tested from Black+Decker, Dyson, Holmes, Honeywell, Lasko, Rowenta and Vornado.

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

How we tested

In our initial round of testing, we first tested 13 fans over four summer weeks to find the most effective and efficient indoor fans available. Then, in our latest round of testing, we tested two additional fans over four spring weeks to see if our former picks stood the test of time or if any our new models proved pick-worthy instead. In both of our testing pools, we included oscillator/oscillating fans, bladeless fans and other electric fans that were adept at circulating the air in our basement. Some fans had a battery-powered remote control and some did not.

To test the fans, we unboxed, assembled and ran the fans for hours while we were sleeping, reading and writing in the room. We took notes on ease of setup, design and features, customization, performance, energy efficiency, noise level, battery, warranty, user manual, ease of cleaning, price and more.

We set up all the fans, one at a time, in the same spot and plugged into the same outlet in our approximately 1,250-square-foot finished basement. We tracked the falling temperature of the room during our tests using the SensorPush HTP.xw Wireless Thermometer/Hygrometer with its iOS app on an iPhone 11; the SensorPush device was calibrated using a Boveda One-Step Calibration Kit. This was the same SensorPush we used when we tested the best dehumidifiers. This time, we noted the temperature of the basement before and after our two-hour tests by examining reports sent from the SensorPush.

To track energy consumption, we plugged each fan into a P3 International Kill A Watt EZ electricity usage monitor while running them for two hours at their highest speed, without oscillation. We noted the amps and watts used during those two hours.

We also recorded the fans’ noise levels by using the Sound Level Meter (SLM) app from the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) on our iPhone 11, which was set upon a table 36 inches away from the fan. We measured the noise levels produced by each fan over a one-hour period while running at its highest speed without oscillation (if the fan was capable of oscillating) in our quiet basement using the NIOSH app.

While all the models we tested made an audible hum in operation, in the end, each unit measured at an average level of around 52.6 decibels (dB) — no louder than the hum of a running refrigerator and not loud enough to interfere with conversation or sleep. Therefore, any of the fans we tested would be suitable for most spaces around your house, home office or dorm room.

Setup

  • Plug and play: Can we unbox an assembled fan and immediately plug it in?

  • Ease of assembly: Is the fan easy to assemble?

  • Tools required: Can you assemble the fan by hand, or do you need tools of any kind? Are those tools included?

  • Downloadable app: Is there an iOS and Android app available?

  • Smart plug: Can the fan work with a smart plug?


Design and features

  • Footprint: Does the fan have an upright, vertical build?

  • Materials: Are the fan parts made of plastic or metal?

  • Buttons: Are the fan’s buttons easy to reach and intuitive to learn?

  • Cord: How long is the fan’s power cord?

  • Extension cord: Does the manufacturer recommend using the fan with an extension cord?

  • Oscillation: Does the fan move from side to side, or does it oscillate within a fixed base?

  • Fixed or oscillating: Does the fan give you the choice between oscillating or stationary?

  • Oscillation angle: Can the fan’s oscillation angle be customized between 45, 90, 180 and 350 degrees?

  • Control panel: Does the fan have one and does it show ambient temperature readings?

  • Autopilot mode: Does the fan have this mode, and does it work when the room temperature hits a certain threshold?

  • Voice controls: Does the fan support Alexa or Siri and the like?


Customization

  • Control via an app: Can you control the fan using a mobile app?

  • Scheduling: Does the fan offer you the ability to set a custom schedule?

  • Adjustable height: Can you adjust the height of the fan’s stand?

  • Pivot or tilt: Does the fan’s head pivot or tilt?

  • Airflow: Can you adjust the direction and angle of the airflow?

  • Settings: Is it easy to adjust the fan’s settings?

  • Mobility: Can the fan be moved from room to room with a built-in carrying handle?


Performance

  • Reliability: Does the fan work as intended?

  • Room size: Can the fan cool off a medium to large room on a hot day?

  • Programmable timer: Does the fan come with a sleep timer? How many hours can you preprogram it to run before turning off?

  • Settings: Does the fan have a mode that simulates a natural breeze?

  • Remote control: Does the fan come with a remote control and are batteries included?

  • Docking: Does the fan provide a docking option to keep the remote control stored when not is use?

  • Speed settings: How many speeds does the fan operate in?

  • Noise level: Do the settings range from a near-silent, 26 dB Sleep setting and a comfortably quiet, 28 dB White Noise setting up to more powerful settings?

  • Range: How many feet does the fan’s airflow reach?

  • Night mode: Does the fan’s control panel have a night mode so you can turn off the screen or buttons when napping or sleeping?


Energy efficiency

  • Watts used: Is the fan energy efficient? Does it draw 36 watts or fewer at full blast?


Battery

  • Requirement: Does the fan require batteries?

  • Type: What kind of battery does the fan or fan’s remote control use?


Warranty

  • Length: How many years is the included warranty good for?

  • Type: What does the warranty cover?


User manual

  • Languages: How many languages is the user manual available in?

  • Usefulness: Does the user manual help you with setup and use?

  • Type: Is a printed user manual included out of the box and can it also be found online?


Ease of cleaning

  • Removable grille: Does the fan have grilles, and are they removable to clean?

  • Blades: Does the fan have blades, and are they accessible to clean?

  • Filter: Does the fan require a filter, and does it come with one filter replacement out of the box?

  • Filter replacement: How easy is it to order another filter?

Other cooling fans we tested

Left to right: A few of the tower fans we tested from Vornado, Dyson and Lasko.

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

Tower fans

$850 at Dyson and Best Buy

Our former pick for best splurge fan, the Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool Formaldehyde HP09 also impressed us with its effective cooling, quiet performance, solid build and ease of use. It can also be used as a space heater and air purifier. Like our winning pick (the Humidity+Cool PH04), this fan can even monitor levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and formaldehyde (thus the name). As you’d expect (and likely demand given the price), this Dyson fan was solidly built and stable in construction. The HP09 also offered fine-grained control over its various settings and a tool-free, simple assembly. Its front panel controls are well-designed, including a LCD screen that is easy to scroll through. Its remote also attaches magnetically to the unit for storage. Its accompanying app that not only lets you control the unit but also monitor pollutant levels. Pick it up if you’re interested in streamlining your space and tossing your separate space heater, air purifier and fan appliances.

From $63 at Amazon; $70 at Walmart

This Lasko fan was easy for us to set up, but once set up, we found the unit to be a bit wobbly in its base, unlike the sturdy bases of the Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room HYF290B tower fan and the Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool Formaldehyde HP09 tower fan. The wobbling action of the Lasko did not happen on its own during testing, but rather, after we gently pushed the tower from side to side; it rocked from side to side as a result. It was not sturdy and rigid like the other towers we tested, which gave us pause in recommending it to anyone with pets or small children, for example. We did like the remote control of this fan, which let us turn it on and off, select its three speed settings, set it to oscillate and set the timer for one, two and four hours. This timer button was surprisingly missing from the remote control of the Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room HYF290B tower fan, even though the Honeywell includes a timer on its control panel on top of the unit.

$110 $92 at Amazon

We found this Vornado fan simple to set up, as it slid in almost one solid piece out of the box, but we needed to assemble its two base halves together and then screw them tighter together using a screwdriver. A screwdriver was not needed to assemble the Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room HYF290B tower fan, which was the easiest tower fan for us to set up. The Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool Formaldehyde HP09 tower fan did not require us to find a screwdriver either. We thought the Vornado Whole Room was quite sturdy and powerful, as it cooled off our basement testing area, but we quickly realized that it does not oscillate from side to side; rather, it circulates the room’s air from within the unit. This is unlike the Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room HYF290B tower fan, which we set to oscillate on eight different speed settings. The Vornado Whole Room 184 is also taller than the Lasko 36-Inch 2511 tower fan and is much taller than the Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool Formaldehyde HP09 tower fan. The Vornado Whole Room 184 is also just slightly taller than the Honeywell QuietSet Whole Room HYF290B tower fan. This makes the Vornado a fan that’s a bit more difficult to include in your room without it being in the way.

One of the standing fans we tested.

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

Standing or pedestal fans

$66 $61 at Amazon; $70 $61 at Walmart

This Black+Decker fan was easy to assemble — that is, until we tried to attach its rear and front grilles together. There is a plastic ring that secures the two grilles together, but we found the fan’s one flimsy clasp on the front grille was not enough to firmly secure the two grilles together. We kept wrestling with the three parts of the fan to make them work; it took us about 20 minutes longer to assemble this fan than it did all the others in our testing. Once assembled, though, we were able to set the fan to oscillate and found it cooled off our testing room nicely. However, we cannot recommend this fan due to its unnecessary difficulty in assembling what should be a simple grille attachment.

$60 at Walmart

This Honeywell fan was simple for us to assemble, and we found it sturdy as well. We could easily make it oscillate from side to side, and we thought it provided good airflow during testing. Its construction and materials are markedly similar (almost identical) to that of the Black+Decker BFSD116B standing fan. The only differences we found during testing was that the Honeywell Double-Blade standing fan has a shorter rod/extension rod, but its front and rear plastic grilles are much simpler to assemble than those of the Black+Decker, thanks to the Honeywell’s five well-placed and well-designed clips on its rear grille.

$30 at The Home Depot

This Lasko fan was easy for us to assemble, too. It also operated quietly enough in the room that we didn’t notice it made much noise while we tested it. But we noticed it was shorter and weighed less than the other pedestal fans we tested, making it less durable and sturdy. We also noticed that it was quite easy for us to pull up on the fan’s rod (to lift the fan up to carry it across the room) but have the entire rod lift out from its base when we did so. Luckily, we only tried moving it when it was turned off, but we could see how this could be a potentially dangerous action should anyone try to move it even a foot away while it’s turned on.

$150 $143 at Amazon; $170 at Walmart

This Vornado fan did not require us to do much assembling other than putting its head onto its rod and curved U-shaped base. It doesn’t come with a remote control, and it doesn’t feature a control panel. It simply has a three-speed dial on the back of the unit’s circular head, much like the Lasko 2521 standing fan. The whole look of this Vornado Whole Room 783 reminded us of the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC circulator fan, as its head is basically the same, just larger, and it sits on a long metal pole and base. Though it’s powerful and well-made, we think the other fans we tested would look better in a home or dorm environment, as the Vornado is kind of bulky and hard to miss visually.

Left to right: Some of the floor fans we tested from Honeywell, Vornado, Black+Decker and Lasko.

Suzanne Kattau/CNN Underscored

Circulator or floor fans

$20 $18 at Amazon; $25 at Walmart

This Black+Decker fan was able to fit onto our testing desk with ease, its footprint taking up less space than the other circulator fans we tested. Its three speed settings were easy for us to adjust during testing; all we had to do was simply turn the small manual dial on the lower right-hand side of the fan in a clockwise direction. Its dial was easier for us to reach than the blue dial on the back of the Lasko Wind Machine 3300 circulator fan, but we found the clicking sounds the Black+Decker 9-Inch BFB09W circulator fan’s dial made as we turned it through its three speed settings to be loud — as loud as the three-speed dial on the back of the Honeywell Turbo Force HT-900 circulator fan. In contrast, we were able to adjust the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC circulator fan’s speed dial with one continuous, smooth motion, with just a barely audible click when the fan is turned from the “off” position.

$30 at Staples; $37 at Walmart

This Honeywell fan is powerful for its size and provides a good, cooling airflow. We tilted its head to see how many angles we could direct its airflow in but found the circular motion of the tilt to be choppy and loud, unlike the smooth, silent tilting action of the previous winner, the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC circulator fan. The Honeywell also has a small speed dial on the back of its head that only fits the tips of our index finger and thumb comfortably. The dial let us turn it to set three different speeds, and with each turn, we heard a loud clicking sound. This was unlike the dial on the Vornado, which lets you grip it comfortably as you smoothly and quietly rotate it around clockwise and back.

$50 $40 at Amazon

This Lasko fan was easy for us to set up since, like the other circulator fans we tested, it requires no assembly; we just lifted it out of its box and plugged it in. We liked its fully tiltable head, which we were able to push all the way around (almost 360 degrees) to cool off either side of our testing area. But we found its blue control knob on the back of the fan to be a bit cumbersome to reach, as we had to tilt the fan down to access it, and even then, the knob felt a bit wobbly in our grip. This was unlike the firm, smooth motion we enjoyed while turning the knob on the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC circulator fan. The Lasko Wind Machine 3300 circulator fan is also much bigger than the other floor fans we tested, so we had trouble sitting it atop our desk, which quite frankly, it isn’t designed to do. This is unlike the Honeywell Turbo Force HT-900 and the Black+Decker 9-Inch BFB09W circulator fans we tested since they’re compact enough to fit atop a desk or table as well as the floor. Even though we appreciated Lasko’s built-in carrying handle on top of the fan, its 9.25-pound weight made it more difficult for us to carry from one part of our testing area than the 3.44-pound Vornado Energy Smart 533DC circulator fan.

$80 $70 at Amazon; $90 at JCPenney

Our former pick for best floor fan, the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC was lighter than the others we tested and easier to carry around our testing space, even though it was more sturdily built and easier to adjust than its competitors. At 3.44 pounds, the Vornado was significantly lighter than some of the other fans, like the 9.25-pound Lasko Wind Machine 3300. Rubber grips on its underside kept it stable on any setting, and it resisted toppling when we tried to jostle it, unlike some of the other lightweight models like the Black+Decker BFB09W. The Vornado’s directional settings were easy to select and secure in operation, and while it wasn’t quite as adjustable as the Lasko Wind Machine 3300, it gave us a good range of usable settings. We also preferred the Vornado’s silver speed dial, which let us adjust settings with one continuous, smooth, quiet motion, over the controls on the other circulators.

The one downside we found was that, technically, the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC was the loudest of the bunch, though all of the fans we tested were quieter than our reference Conair 1875 hair dryer set on low. We didn’t find even the Vornado’s noise distracting enough while we worked, read or slept nearby in the same room. Lastly, the Vornado Energy Smart 533DC circulator fan is covered by a 10-year limited warranty, which is much longer than the one-year warranties of the Black+Decker BFB09W, the Honeywell HT-900 and the Lasko 3300 circulator fans we tested.

What is the best fan out there?

Best cooling fans of 2024, tested by editors

Comments

0

0/2000

Guest Posts

If you are interested in sending in a Guest Blogger Submission,welcome to write for us!

Your Name:(required)

Your Email:(required)

Subject:

Your Message:(required)

0/2000